Caerphilly Observer
Member Sign in Manage Membership
Become a Member - no ads
Menu
  • News
    • Senedd
    • Business
    • Newport
    • Opinion
  • Sport
    • Rugby union
    • Football
  • Membership & Subscriptions
  • Notices
  • Advertise
  • About
  • Sponsored Content
Menu

Pontllanfraith leisure centre closure decision “unreasonably” made

News | Niall Griffiths - Local Democracy Reporting Service | Published: 12:00, Thursday June 20th, 2019.
Last updated: 17:09, Thursday June 27th, 2019

Campaigners fighting to stop the closure of Pontllanfraith Leisure Centre outside Cardiff Justice Centre

The decision to close Pontllanfraith leisure centre was “unreasonably” made without being properly costed, a court has heard.

Caerphilly County Borough Council is defending a legal challenge against the closure, which has been pursued by the authority since 2017.

Cabinet members deferred its proposals until the adoption of a 10-year sport and active recreation strategy, which promised investment in four strategic leisure centres, while others could close.

But the Administrative Court in Cardiff heard the cost of implementing the strategy was not known to senior councillors before it was passed in November 2018.

Christian Howells, presenting the case against the council, argued that officers did not make the strategy’s efficiency clear to councillors or residents during a public consultation.

“The adoption of the strategy was unreasonable as it was made without knowing the costings,” said Mr Howells.

“Costings should have been present at the outset in the overall strategy, and that is the flaw of the council’s decision-making process.

“The cabinet didn’t know if their chief financial officer would approve of the capital expenditure on the new sites.”

The court also heard that the council failed to consider alternatives to closing Pontllanfraith, including the possibility of a community asset transfer (CAT) to a non-profit organisation.

Mr Howells said: “Officers dismissed this out of hand and said there had been no mention of CAT in consultation, which is incorrect.

“This meant cabinet did not have all the information required to make an informed decision.”

Matthew Paul, on behalf of the council, said the strategy provided a “loose framework” within which the council can take secondary decisions, such as investing or closing leisure centres.

Accusations that the strategy failed to meet the council’s statutory obligation to secure continuous improvement in its duties were also dismissed by Mr Paul.

“The strategy can’t realistically be criticised as it’s about efficiency and making best use of dwindling resources,” he said.

“It intends to bring about measurable improvements to the health and wellbeing of people.”

Mr Paul said there was an “enormous” amount of material available to allow cabinet members to make their decision, including the negative impacts on people with protected characteristics such as disability and age.

The court heard that 26 per cent of people living in Caerphilly county borough are registered disabled.

This was taken into account “with a heavy heart”, added Mr Paul, and that any adverse impact would be mitigated, such as the increased investment at Newbridge.

Regarding the lack of consideration for a CAT, Mr Paul said there was “no other realistic or viable alternative” to closing Pontllanfraith leisure centre.

An order from the High Court has prevented the council from taking any further steps towards closing the site on June 30 until the conclusion of the legal claim.

A judgement is expected from Mr Justice Swift on June 24.

LDRS

Latest News

  • Substation near The Square, Abertridwr, pictured in June 2025
    Substation’s beauty salon makeover plan wins approvalMonday, September 29, 2025
  • Mary Gittins with her Paralympic bronze medal
    Paralympian shares story of bowls bronze medal triumphMonday, September 29, 2025
  • First Minister Eluned Morgan
    First Minister to remain ‘ultimate judge’ of ministers’ conductMonday, September 29, 2025
  • General view of the proposed development site at Winding Wheel Lane, Penallta, pictured in June 2025
    Plans for new homes and supermarket next to former colliery siteMonday, September 29, 2025
  • The greyhound racing track in Ystrad Mynach
    Wales to ban greyhound racing by 2030Monday, September 29, 2025
  • Rugby round-up: Penallta, Caerphilly, Blackwood, and more earn cup winsMonday, September 29, 2025

Find out how the communities of Caerphilly County Borough get their names

Caerphilly

Legal & Public Notices

  • Notice of application for a premises licence: Hanbury Road, BargoedThursday, September 25, 2025
  • Notice of application for a variation of a premises licence: Pontygwindy Industrial EstateThursday, September 18, 2025
  • Caerphilly County Borough Council public noticesThursday, September 18, 2025
  • Caerphilly County Borough Council public noticesThursday, September 4, 2025
© 2009-2024 Caerphilly Media Ltd, Caerphilly Miners Centre for the Community Watford Road Caerphilly, CF83 1BJ. Incorporated in Wales No. 07604006.